Luminant CEO says EPA air plan would cost Texas big

Emissions-resize-150x150

The economic impact on Texas coal units from the re-dispatch from coal to gas is right in EPA's own modeling for the agency's Clean Power Plan, which would result in 72 million megawatt-hours of reduced output by the Texas coal fleet by 2020.

That's a 52% reduction of coal-fired generation from the 2012 baseline, said Luminant Chief Executive Officer Mac McFarland to an Aug. 15 joint workshop called by the Public Utility Commission of Texas and also attended by officials of the Railroad Commission of Texas and the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality.

The purpose of the meeting was for commissioners from the three agencies to gather information on the impact that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's proposed CO2-control rule will have on the state's electric generation and transmission, regulations, energy efficiency and what the costs would be.

Luminant has Texas' largest competitive power generation business. It operates in the Electric Reliability Council of Texas' (ERCOT) wholesale power market with a generation mix of coal, natural gas and nuclear energy, and it is one of the biggest purchasers of wind in the state and nation.

“The Clean Power Plan overlooks the impact on consumers in Texas and would require drastic changes to the ERCOT market,” McFarland said. “It not only overestimates the feasible efficiencies at existing power plants, but also the called-for steep increase in renewable energy sources. The plan disproportionately impacts Texas, and, in our opinion, it oversteps the law.

“As rolled out by the EPA, the Clean Power Plan is described as a vision to cut carbon dioxide emissions and fight climate change by providing states ‘flexibility' in developing ways to attain the proposed standards. But as lofty visions often do when they collide with reality, the Clean Power Plan is simply unworkable and doesn't balance the economy, energy supply, reliability and the environment.

“Taken all together, this is a pretty big price the U.S. - and, more specifically, Texas - are being asked to pay for a very small reduction in greenhouse gas emissionsthat we must remember are globally generated and transient. … U.S carbon emissions stood at 17 percent of the world total in 2011, with the power sector covering just over one third of that. Within the U.S. power sector carbon emissions, a majority came from coal. But some perspective is needed here.

Compared to the rest of the world, U.S. coal generation contributed less than five percent of the world total and Texas coal generation even less - lower than one percent. So what this plan expects from the nation and from Texas makes no difference when considered globally with China, Russia, India, developed countries and emerging economies all over the world, which have significant - and increasing - CO2 emissions.”

EPA's plan would also end the careful balance intended under the Clean Air Act, in which Texas and other states partner with the EPA to comply with the act, McFarland said. “We've seen this partnership work many times, most recently with the MATS rule. Instead, Texas would cede a significant portion of its authority to run its energy market to the EPA.

“We also don't think this rule is legal under the Clean Air Act. Simply, by trying to push its authority ‘beyond the fence line' of power plants into regulating Texas' entire energy sector from fuel sources to generation dispatch on the ERCOT grid to the end user, the EPA has pushed beyond what the act allows. Lawsuits have already been filed and doubtless more will come, and the courts will hear them. But beyond the legal questions, what's our view for what the rule means for the power generation sector? And for Texas? And what does it mean for Luminant, since about 70 percent of our generation comes from coal?”

Texas must bear 18% of the total U.S. carbon cuts under the plan, yet it is responsible for only 11% of carbon emissions in the 2012 baseline, McFarland said. Texas and many other states fall below the national average of 991 lbs/MWh. But on an absolute tonnage basis, make no mistake, Texas must reduce the most tonnage by far, he said.

This article was republished with permission from GenerationHub.

Sponsored by FLSmidth

Related Articles

Report: US energy storage market poised to grow 250% this year

Deployments for energy storage in the U.S. is expected to grow from 62-MW in 2014 to 220-MW in 2015 – a 250 percent increase- according to a report conducted by GTM Research and Energy Storage Association (ESA).

Siemens upgrades offshore wind turbine, increases capacity

Siemens’ (NYSE: SI) offshore wind turbine, the SWT-6.0-154, has reached a milestone for its gearless turbine design, increasing output capacity.

Follow Power Engineering on Twitter
Latest News

PNM files ownership plan, coal supply deal with regulators

New Mexico's largest electric provider says it's on track to meeting a deadline for submittin...

Oklahoma attorney general challenges EPA's clean-air plan

A plan by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to reduce emissions from coal-fired power ...

Wave Energy Week will mix marine energy developers with traditional hydropower

Oregon Gov. Kate Brown, Democrat, has proclaimed “July 13-17, 2015 to be Oregon Wave Week in ...

Public Service Company of Oklahoma seeks rate increase

Public Service Company of Oklahoma is asking for a 13.6 percent rate increase it says is need...

GAO looks at reliability impacts of changing power generation mix

The Government Accountability Office (GAO) on June 29 released a study provided a month befor...

On the day after MATS decision, Bernstein sees only a limited reprieve for coal units

In light of the U.S. Supreme Court ruling against the EPA's Mercury and Air Toxics Standards ...

Pence says Indiana will not comply with coal plant regulations

Indiana will not comply with President Barack Obama's plan to battle climate change by requir...

Westermost Rough offshore wind park enters operations

The 210-MW offshore wind power plant, Westermost Rough, has entered operations. The project w...

Power Engineering Current Issue

02/01/2015
Volume 119, Issue 2
1502PE-cover
Products Showcase
Dynamic Fluoride Ion cleaning DFIC of industrial natural gas turbines Hi-Tech Furnace Systems

Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning of IGT Parts

The Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning (DFIC) Process from Hi-Tech Furnace Systems is able to clean deep, narrow cracks of oxides by cycling between negative, atmospheric, and positive pressure.

Archived Articles

2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015

Buyers Guide Product Listings

Engine Starting Systems

Ingersoll Rand air starters are flexible, effic...

Strikesorb Product Family

Only Strikesorb® Surge Protective Devices (SPDs...
Power Industry Wire News

NW Natural Announces Dividend and Schedules Conference Call to Review Results for the Three and Six Months Ended June 30, 2015

NW Natural Announces Dividend and Schedules Conference Call to Review Results for the T...

Vantage Drilling Responds to News Reports Regarding Petrobras

Vantage Drilling Responds to News Reports Regarding Petrobras

National Grid Drives Innovation Through REV Demonstration Projects

National Grid Drives Innovation Through REV Demonstration Projects

Cardinal Resources' $28.8 Million Cameroon Red Bird Contract Advances; Company Expects Financing Completed, Implementation, in Q3-15

Cardinal Resources' $28.8 Million Cameroon Red Bird Contract Advances; Company Expects ...

Letter From CGE Energy (McKenzie Bay Intl.) President Bryan Zaplitny

Letter From CGE Energy (McKenzie Bay Intl.) President Bryan Zaplitny

Power Engineering

Article Archives for Power Engineering Magazine

Continuing Education

Professional Development Hours

To access a course listing associated to a specific topic listed below, click on the topic of choice from the list below.

Latest Energy Jobs

View more Job Listings >>