Constellation back out of Calvert Cliffs

The nuclear renaissance in the United States may not be ending just yet, but it surely took a step backward this week. The demand for energy, a growing emphasis on decreasing carbon dioxide emissions and federal loan guarantees set off talks of a nuclear revival in the States just a few years ago. But the economic decline has driven down the demand for energy along with the price of competing energy sources, especially natural gas, with the threat of shale gas keeping that price down for a potentially long time.

In the midst of this, Baltimore-based Constellation Energy announced last week that they have pulled out of negotiations on a $7.5 billion federal loan guarantee to build a 1,600 MW reactor in Maryland with its partner Electricite de France (EDF), France’s government-backed utility and nuclear fleet operator.

In an Oct. 8 letter to Dan Poneman, deputy secretary of the U.S. Department of Energy, Constellation Energy Chief Operating Officer Michael Wallace said Constellation Energy does not see a “timely path to reaching a workable set of terms and conditions” to build a third unit at Calvert Cliffs in an “economically reasonable and statutorily justifiable manner.”

The statement also said that the high estimate of the credit subsidy would force Constellation and its partners to pay the U.S. Treasury 11.6 percent, or $880 million, in order to obtain the loan guarantee for Calvert Cliffs 3 (CC3).

“Such a sum would clearly destroy the project’s economics (or the economics for any nuclear project for that matter) and was dramatically out of line with both our own and independent assessments of what the figure should reasonably be,” the statement read.

In February the first loan guarantee for a nuclear plant was awarded under the provisions of the Energy Policy Act of 2005. The award of $8.3 billion for two additional reactors at the Vogtle plant in Georgia is conditional until the plant receives the combine construction and operating license from the NRC, which is expected in 2011. Southern Co. can recover costs during construction under Georgia law since it is a regulated market with a state utility commission in place. In Maryland, power companies operate under a merchant market. Merchant markets do not have a utility commission and can only regain construction costs after the plant is commercially operable, leaving those companies with no guarantee that they will recover those investments.

“Merchant nuclear projects – unregulated projects in electricity markets – will only be built if project profits are high enough to justify the investment,” said Edward Kee with NERA Economic Consulting.

Several reports out say that UniStar Nuclear Energy, a Constellation Energy and EDF Inc. joint company, along with its partners have already spent more than $600 million on the project. Still, UniStar said it has not withdrawn its application for a federal loan guarantee and also said that no decision has been made regarding the future of CC3.

"There are a lot of people that are spending a lot of money right now waiting on these loan guarantees and that is how cost overruns happen and that is what drives the cost of the projects up when you sit in suspense," said Danny Roderick, GE Hitachi Nuclear Energy's senior vice president for new plant projects, during Power Engineering magazine's Nuclear Power Executive Roundtable being published in the November issue.

And while natural gas prices are low now, John Herron, president, CEO & chief nuclear officer of Entergy Nuclear who was also speaking at the Nuclear Power Executive Roundtable, said that natural gas is a good choice, but it is still putting out CO2.

“People should start comparing nuclear power accurately,” Herron said. “Let’s put the facts on the table, let them speak for themselves and I guarantee that clean nuclear energy will win out every time.”

The Beginning
In 2008, EDF paid $4.5 billion for a 49.9 percent share of Constellation’s nuclear share after energy trading losses hurt the company financially.

UniStar was developed with the idea of helping start the nuclear renaissance in the U.S. with a new fleet of nuclear power plants using the Areva EPR reactor design. But the summer of 2010 saw disagreement between EDF and Areva over the rising costs of the construction of an Areva reactor in Finland, reported The New York Times.

An e-mailed statement, Areva said that “the news that Constellation considers the terms of a proposed DOE loan guarantee 'unworkable' is cause for concern, but we remain hopeful that an agreement can still be reached to continue development of a U.S. EPR reactor in southern Maryland.”

Early last week, The Washington Post reported that Constellation Energy was in disagreement with EDF over a deal in the purchase agreement. The disagreement reportedly stemmed from a put option, agreed upon in 2008, which allows Constellation to sell gas and coal fired power stations to EDF for up to $2 billion. The put option was intended to offer Constellation additional financial backing, if needed. But now, the value of power plant assets has dropped as commodity prices have gone south and reports by Financial Times state that EDF does not believe Constellation can force them to purchase the plants under the original contract.

A report by IHS CERA in July found that construction costs for a variety of plants—ranging from wind to fossil to nuclear—rose for the first time since the first quarter of 2008. The report found that between the third quarter of 2009 and the first quarter of 2010, costs in North America rose 1 percent and in Europe 3 percent. IHS CERA’s construction cost index found that steel costs have risen 2 percent for North America and 6 percent for Europe. Electrical prices, driven by the rise of copper prices, posted the largest increases: 15 percent in North America and 22 percent in Europe.

“Both UniStar and NRG have been forced to scale back due to delays in receiving the conditional loan guarantees. The delay will clearly slow any efforts to spur any growth and any investment and any creation of jobs,” Mark Marano, Areva senior vice president of U.S. new build operations said during Power Engineering's Nuclear Power Executive Roundtable. “And the result sadly enough - we won’t be just talking about stimulating and adding jobs - the lack of action on loan guarantees could inherently cause the reverse reaction which is just the opposite of what its intent was.”

And EDF said the development of CC3 would generate 4,000 new jobs and bring significant financial investment to Maryland.

With Constellation now backing out of the project, EDF’s ambitions to help lead a nuclear renaissance in the U.S. have all but stopped completely. Constellation did say that the next steps in the loan guarantee process are for EDF to determine.

“This issue of the loan guarantees has to get solved soon. We have to understand what the government’s role is going to be in that,” said Roderick.

Despite the step back in current development, EDF said they remain committed to pursuing new nuclear in the U.S. and said Constellation knows that they were at the finish line with the DOE after making huge investments of time and resources on the federal loan guarantee process.

Subscribe to Nuclear Power International magazine

Sponsored by FLSmidth

Related Articles

Power Engineering, Renewable Energy World announce Projects of the Year!

Editors from Renewable Energy World and Power Engineering reviewed each nominee and selected the four winners based on the technology that was employed as well as the projects’ impact on the industry at large and on the communities in which they were installed.

MHPS to increase output at thermal power plant in Mexico

Mexico’s Federal Electricity Commission (CFE) has awarded Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems, Ltd. (MHPS) a full turnkey order, worth $200 million, to increase the output of Units No.1 through No. 4 at CFE's Río Escondido Thermal Power Plant from 1,200-MW to 1,320-MW.

Follow Power Engineering on Twitter

Latest News

US nuclear reactor shuts down during snowstorm

Officials say a Massachusetts nuclear power plant was forced to shut down during the blizzard...
Natural Ventilation

Power Engineering Photo of the Day

TEPCO Tokyo Electric Power Company water treatment radioactive contaminated Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant Nuclear Regulation Authority

TEPCO to miss radioactive water treatment deadline

Tokyo Electric Power Co. (TEPCO) said it would miss a self-imposed deadline to decontaminate ...
Nuclear Energy Institute NEI nuclear power plants capacity factor generation electricity South Texas Project Braidwood Palo Verde Hope Creek St. Lucie Three Mile Island Surry Peach Bottom Perry Farley Susquehanna Grand Gulf Seabrook Oconee

NEI: U.S. nuclear power plants operated at record capacity factor in 2014

One hundred U.S. nuclear power plants generated electricity at a capacity factor of 92 percen...
Global Nuclear Fuel GNF GE Hitachi Toshiba Cooper nuclear power plant station Nebraska Public Power District nuclear fuel reloads

GNF to provide nuclear fuel reloads to Cooper plant

Global Nuclear Fuel, a joint venture of GE, Hitachi and Toshiba, will continue to provide fue...
River Bend nuclear power plant Louisiana Entergy reactors unplanned shutdown

Special inspections begin at River Bend nuclear power plant

Workers with the NRC began a special inspection at the River Bend nuclear power plant in Loui...

GRDA Breaks Ground on Western Hemisphere’s First 501 J Series Gas Turbine

What will likely be the first Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems 501 J combined-cycle gas turbi...

Fitch downgrades bonds for Colver waste coal power plant in Pennsylvania

Fitch Ratings said Jan. 23 that, due to concerns about an "aging" power plant that ...

Power Engineering Current Issue

03/01/2014
Volume 118, Issue 3
1403PE-cover

Products Showcase

Dynamic Fluoride Ion cleaning DFIC of industrial natural gas turbines Hi-Tech Furnace Systems

Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning of IGT Parts

The Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning (DFIC) Process from Hi-Tech Furnace Systems is able to clean deep, narrow cracks of oxides by cycling between negative, atmospheric, and positive pressure.

Archived Articles

2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013

Power Industry Wire News

Surfrider Foundation Opposes Obama Administration Five-Year Plan to Open Offshore Drilling in the Atlantic and Arctic

Surfrider Foundation Opposes Obama Administration Five-Year Plan to Open Offshore Drill...

Veteran Backhaul Radio Engineer Jeff Rivard Joins LightPointe

Veteran Backhaul Radio Engineer Jeff Rivard Joins LightPointe

Abakan Appoints Stephen Goss as Chief Operating Officer

Abakan Appoints Stephen Goss as Chief Operating Officer

CGE Energy's R.A.M.P. Lighting Maintenance Program Grows to Over 19,000,000 Square Feet in the Midwest

CGE Energy's R.A.M.P. Lighting Maintenance Program Grows to Over 19,000,000 Square Feet...

Falconridge Oil Technologies Signs Letter of Intent With Tubestar of India

Falconridge Oil Technologies Signs Letter of Intent With Tubestar of India

Power Engineering

Article Archives for Power Engineering Magazine

Continuing Education

Professional Development Hours

To access a course listing associated to a specific topic listed below, click on the topic of choice from the list below.

Latest Energy Jobs

View more Job Listings >>