Eight states, New York City to consider landmark emissions lawsuit

23 July 2004 - When a rendering plant persists in stinking up the neighborhood or a dump keeps fouling area drinking-water wells, the victims have a centuries-old friend they can tap to haul the offender into court: the common law of public nuisance.

Now, California and seven other states and New York City are trying to stretch this doctrine to cover emissions neither odorous nor toxic from power plants far outside the neighborhood.

In an unprecedented lawsuit filed Wednesday, the governments' lawyers invoked the federal and state common laws of public nuisance in asking the Manhattan federal District Court to order the nation's five largest electricity suppliers to curb power plant emissions of gases linked to global warming.

"This is a pioneering effort in lawyering," California Attorney General Bill Lockyer said Wednesday in announcing the legal action at a Los Angeles press conference.

It also is the first time government has sued businesses under any grounds over emissions of the climate-altering or greenhouse gases, Lockyer said.

Unlike carbon monoxide and smog-forming nitrogen oxides in auto exhaust, the greenhouse gases - mainly carbon dioxide - are not hazardous to breathe.

The increasing buildup of these gases in the atmosphere, however, can alter Earth's temperature and lead to catastrophic changes in sea levels, water supplies, crop production, disease and wildfires. Like the glass panels of a greenhouse, the gases trap some of the sun's radiation reflected by Earth, raising the atmospheric temperature.

The global warming lawsuit asserts that the electric power industry is the largest contributor in the United States to global climate change, responsible for ten per cent of all carbon dioxide emissions from human activity in the country. And the five power companies named as defendants - American Electric Power Co., Southern Co., Xcel Energy, Cinergy Corp. and Tennessee Valley Authority - generate about 25 per cent of the carbon dioxide from power plants in the nation, the suit states.

The companies own about 175 plants in 20 states, mainly in the South and Midwest, that together emit about 652m t of carbon dioxide every year, according to the suit.

"That's three and one-half times what (carbon dioxide) from California auto emissions are," Lockyer said.

Public nuisance laws borrowed from England have been used since the founding of the United States to remedy local and interstate pollution ranging from sewage to acid rain and even tobacco smoke.

The multistate global warming suit is unprecedented in extending the doctrine to remedy a planetary environmental problem. But the gist of the complaint basically is no different from the neighborhood fight with the smelly hog farm, said James Tierney, a former attorney general of Maine who teaches at Columbia University's law school.

In California, public nuisance cases have ranged from complaints over gold-mining wastes in the 1880s to a lawsuit brought by the South Tahoe Public Utility District against major oil companies for making gasoline containing the chemical MTBE, which has contaminated wells.

"Defendants' emissions of carbon dioxide, by contributing to global warming, constitute a substantial and unreasonable interference with public rights... the right to use, enjoy and preserve the aesthetic and ecological values of the natural world," the lawsuit states.

The power industry Wednesday called the suit irresponsible. "Although the lawsuit alleges harm to the public, the real harm is not the utility companies... but this lawsuit," said Myron Ebell, a spokesman at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, an industry-funded think tank.

"It would force consumers in other states to pay much higher prices for electricity," Ebell said. "The attorneys general are engaging in irresponsible political grandstanding."

The gist of the global-warming complaint basically is no different than the neighborhood fight with the smelly hog farm, Columbia University's Tierney said.

But Columbia University's Tierney countered: "You have a pretty clear harm and you have states coming in to fill the vacuum left by the federal government. It was a courageous thing for the states to do. This is not an easy case. It's too bad we're going around the federal government to do this."

Common-law remedies are at their strongest when the laws enacted by government are either nonexistent or ineffectively enforced, said Clifford Rechtschaffen, a professor of environmental law at Golden Gate University.

"These remedies have receded in visibility and importance with the advent of environmental laws in the 1960s and '70s, but they still remain viable and potentially very powerful tools, especially to fill the gaps in statutory protection," Rechtschaffen said.

With the filing of the global-warming lawsuit, he said, "We are seeing people resorting to common law because of an egregious gap."

Sponsored by FLSmidth

Related Articles

West Virginia panel OKs $550M coal-fired power plant deal

State utility regulators have approved the $550 million transfer of an American Electric Power coal-fired power plant by a subsidiary.

Indiana Michigan nears permit for Rockport Unit 1 SCR project

The Indiana Office of Air Quality (OAQ) is taking comment until Jan. 31 on a draft air permit revision allowing the Indiana Michigan Power unit of American Electric Power (NYSE: AEP) to install a new air emissions control on one of the two, 1,300-MW units at the coal-fired Rockport plant.

Follow Power Engineering on Twitter

Latest News

Wärtsilä to deliver natural gas engines to Montana-Dakota Utilities

Wärtsilä will supply a 19-MW Smart Power Generation power plant to Montana-Dakota Utilities (...

Clyde Bergemann to supply emissions control equipment to Polish cogeneration power plant

The Clyde Bergemann Power Group Europe has received at $10 million contract, from SBB Energy,...

India nuke deals still thorny for US despite 'breakthrough'

India and America's declaration of a breakthrough in contentious nuclear energy cooperation h...

W.Va. bill requires lawmakers to OK state carbon plan

A West Virginia Senate panel is considering requiring lawmakers to approve state plans to com...

US nuclear reactor shuts down during snowstorm

Officials say a Massachusetts nuclear power plant was forced to shut down during the blizzard...
Natural Ventilation

Power Engineering Photo of the Day

Solar energy supporters, utilities spar over legislation

Solar energy supporters are pushing back against a bill backed by Indiana's utilities that wo...
TEPCO Tokyo Electric Power Company water treatment radioactive contaminated Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant Nuclear Regulation Authority

TEPCO to miss radioactive water treatment deadline

Tokyo Electric Power Co. (TEPCO) said it would miss a self-imposed deadline to decontaminate ...

Power Engineering Current Issue

12/01/2014
Volume 118, Issue 12
1412pe-cover1

Products Showcase

Dynamic Fluoride Ion cleaning DFIC of industrial natural gas turbines Hi-Tech Furnace Systems

Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning of IGT Parts

The Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning (DFIC) Process from Hi-Tech Furnace Systems is able to clean deep, narrow cracks of oxides by cycling between negative, atmospheric, and positive pressure.

Archived Articles

2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013

Power Industry Wire News

Walter Energy Suspends Dividend

Walter Energy Suspends Dividend

Synergy Resources Corporation Launches Common Stock Offering

Synergy Resources Corporation Launches Common Stock Offering

Surfrider Foundation Opposes Obama Administration Five-Year Plan to Open Offshore Drilling in the Atlantic and Arctic

Surfrider Foundation Opposes Obama Administration Five-Year Plan to Open Offshore Drill...

Veteran Backhaul Radio Engineer Jeff Rivard Joins LightPointe

Veteran Backhaul Radio Engineer Jeff Rivard Joins LightPointe

Abakan Appoints Stephen Goss as Chief Operating Officer

Abakan Appoints Stephen Goss as Chief Operating Officer

Power Engineering

Article Archives for Power Engineering Magazine

Continuing Education

Professional Development Hours

To access a course listing associated to a specific topic listed below, click on the topic of choice from the list below.

Latest Energy Jobs

View more Job Listings >>