Blackout report may not be ready for a year

DALLAS, Sept. 11, 2003 -- "There is no excuse for that outage, it should not have happened," Michehl Gent, President of the North American Electric Reliability Council (NERC) told the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) Transmission and Distribution conference this week.

A special session was devoted to providing an update on the August 14, 2003 outage that blacked out 62 GW of load in eight northeastern states-largest electrical blackout in US history.

Gent said that restoration of the 62 GW of lost load within 30 hours was "miraculous." He explained that the focus is now on the investigation to find out why it happened and to determine how to improve protection against such outages in the future. The final report of the official investigation into the blackout may not be finished for a year, Gent told the meeting.

"We need to avoid jumping to conclusions," said Gent, "and focus on the facts." He said that it appears the blackout resulted from a "perfect storm" of adverse conditions and events and that the likelihood of another such blackout in the near future is remote. He noted that it took three years to produce a final report on the 1965 blackout, the previous record holder.

The US investigation is being led by the federal Dept. of Energy. Technical analysis is being provided by Gent's organization, which provides voluntary reliability guidelines and standards for the US and part of Canada's high-voltage power delivery system. A key question in the investigation is to determine if transmission system operators complied with NERC's reliability guidelines.

The NERC-led team of engineers is currently collecting information and data records so they can develop a timeline of significant events and identify the root cause of the blackout. Gent said the investigators have obtained about 90% of the relevant data records-several hundred thousand records in all-and reviewed about 40% of them.

So far they've identified about 200 "significant" events. Gent said an investigation of this scope has never been done before. He said the investigation of the last big cascading failure outage in the US, the 1996 western system blackout, was "simple" compared to this one.

Gent said that generating plant outages at the time of the blackout were not a significant contributor. He also said that no equipment-with the exception of one generator-was destroyed as a result of the outage.

One problem the team has encountered is determining the reliability of time stamps on the data records. In order to develop an accurate sequence of events from data from all the companies involved in the outage, the time stamps must be consistent. "Were all computer clocks synchronized," he asked. He noted that if records from digital fault recorders are not linked to a standard time, "it's not worth having them."

If we leap to conclusions, said Gent, we might conclude that all 50 states should be isolated as Texas is. He said he feels it will be better to improve controls for the existing systems and have a more effective compliance program to enforce the rules of operating synchronized high voltage grids. Gent said NERC has been pushing for federal reliability legislation for five years. The legislation currently in Congress does give NERC teeth to better enforce its standards, ranging from exposure of violators to fines. He said the legislation is "very close to being law."

Another expert at the IEEE meeting, Damir Novosel, Senior Vice President of KEMA, said, "We believe protection was big part of this event." He said that protection system failures, misoperation, and outdated settings were involved in 70% of past North American blackout events.

Carson Taylor, principal engineer for transmission operations and planning at Bonneville Power Authority said reviews of four cascading failures in the western interconnection between 1994 and 1996 showed that the best protection is protection depth, "Do everything you can." The biggest western outage was the loss of 30 GW of load in August, 1996. He noted that a common problem in these blackouts was the tripping of generators at a time when they were in no danger of experiencing damage.

A spokesman for American Electric Power reported the sequence of circuit breaker actions on August 14 on the 138-kV and 345-kV lines that connect AEP with First Energy in northern Ohio, noting that the AEP system stayed up for the most part. He said that there was at least one tree contact related failure early in the sequence and a tree contact fire caused by a line sag later in the sequence. He said the AEP system survived because it kept load and generation in balance, its protective equipment operated as designed, operators kept in contact with their neighboring utilities, and the AEP grid is robust.


Sponsored by FLSmidth

Related Articles

Indiana Michigan Power I&M AEP American Electric Power solar power projects substations

I&M plans five solar power projects

Indiana Michigan Power (I&M), a subsidiary of American Electric Power (NYSE: AEP), said it is planning a $38 million project to build five solar power plants totaling 16 MW of capacity.

AEP picks Oniqua to optimize power gen inventory

American Electric Power (AEP, NYSE: AEP) picked Oniqua Intelligent MRO to optimize its inventory across its generation, transmission and distribution (T&D) assets.

Follow Power Engineering on Twitter
Latest News

EIA: Coal-fired generation alive and well in the coming decade

Coal-fired power generation from existing plants will increase through 2025, this according t...

Report: Nuke dump radiation leak could have been prevented

A radiation leak that forced the indefinite closure of the federal government's only undergro...

Areva’s nuclear reactor vessel flaws may be “costly”

The French nuclear regulator says anomalies found in Areva’s nuclear reactor technology are “...

Southern Power acquires 32MW solar project from First Solar

Southern Co. (NYSE: SO) subsidiary, Southern Power, has acquired controlling interest in...

Second robot completes survey of Fukushima reactor containment vessel

A second shape-shifting robot completed a survey from inside of the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear...

PacifiCorp considers joining California ISO

PacifiCorp signed a memorandum of understanding to explore full participation in the Californ...

Herbert: Uranium shouldn't be in Utah before federal review

Gov. Gary Herbert said Thursday that he wants federal regulators to review how hazardous a ty...

Environmentalists press for bill to expand solar power

Environmentalists are urging lawmakers to back a bill they say would help more residents inve...

Power Engineering Current Issue

01/01/2015
Volume 119, Issue 1
1501pe-cover-lg
Products Showcase
Dynamic Fluoride Ion cleaning DFIC of industrial natural gas turbines Hi-Tech Furnace Systems

Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning of IGT Parts

The Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning (DFIC) Process from Hi-Tech Furnace Systems is able to clean deep, narrow cracks of oxides by cycling between negative, atmospheric, and positive pressure.

Archived Articles

2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015

Power Industry Wire News

Dais Analytic Corporation Appoints Eliza Wang to Board of Directors

Dais Analytic Corporation Appoints Eliza Wang to Board of Directors

Magnum Hunter Resources Chairman and CEO to Present at IPAA OGIS New York 2015

Magnum Hunter Resources Chairman and CEO to Present at IPAA OGIS New York 2015

GEI Global Energy Corp. Explores Solar Opportunities

GEI Global Energy Corp. Explores Solar Opportunities

Envision Solar Installs Solar-Powered EV Charging Stations in San Francisco as Part of "Driving on Sunshine" Campaign

Envision Solar Installs Solar-Powered EV Charging Stations in San Francisco as Part of ...

ZBB Energy and Solar Power, Inc. (SPI) Announce Global Strategic Partnership With an Initial Supply Agreement Valued at Between $80 Million and $120 Million

ZBB Energy and Solar Power, Inc. (SPI) Announce Global Strategic Partnership With an In...

Power Engineering

Article Archives for Power Engineering Magazine

Continuing Education

Professional Development Hours

To access a course listing associated to a specific topic listed below, click on the topic of choice from the list below.

Latest Energy Jobs

View more Job Listings >>