Sierra Pacific sues natural gas suppliers

LAS VEGAS, April 22, 2003 -- Sierra Pacific Resources and its Las Vegas-based electric utility, Nevada Power Co., on Monday filed suit in federal court against several natural gas providers including El Paso Corp., Sempra Energy and Dynegy Holdings for alleged restraint of trade, fraud, violation of Nevada's RICO Act and civil conspiracy.

The suit, filed in U.S. District Court in Las Vegas, seeks at least $600 million in compensatory, punitive and other damages.

The suit contends that the defendants "planned and executed schemes designed to reduce or control supplies, drive up or control prices, eliminate competition, cause price instability, increase volatility in wholesale prices and defraud customers in the product market for delivered natural gas ... ." It adds that "anticompetitive and fraudulent behavior ... not only harmed competition for delivered natural gas, but also produced exorbitant and illegal profits for the defendants."

Named in the suit are Houston-based El Paso and several of its subsidiaries, San Diego-based Sempra and its Southern California Gas and San Diego Gas & Electric subsidiaries, and Houston-based Dynegy and some of its subsidiaries. Houston-based Enron Corporation and certain of its subsidiaries, including Enron North America, are listed as co-conspirators but cannot be made a party to the suit because they are in bankruptcy proceedings.

Specifically, the five-count suit contends:

-- That as a result of the defendants' conspiracies and fraudulent behavior, the plaintiffs were forced to enter into natural gas purchase contracts "at artificially high, supracompetitive prices."

-- That between 1996 and 2001, El Paso, Sempra, Dynegy, Enron and their subsidiaries conspired to decrease competition by restricting the amount of pipeline capacity and fuel available to Nevada Power and others; decreased natural gas supplies and drove up prices by illegally withholding pipeline capacity; maintained control over output and prices by manipulating natural gas price indexes; and harmed market competition and the plaintiffs by driving up prices and increasing the volatility of natural gas supplies.

The suit states that the foundation for the conspiracy was laid during a secret meeting in late September 1996 in Phoenix, Arizona, between the president of El Paso subsidiary El Paso Natural Gas Company, the president of SoCal Gas and an executive vice president of SDG&E.

The suit further contends that the Phoenix meeting "was only one of a number of surreptitious meetings and communications in which the conspiracy was planned and carried out" and "was just one of the pieces of El Paso's conspiracy ... to control output and increase prices."

The suit cites a written agenda for the Phoenix meeting that deals with a joint venture for the Samalayuca pipeline in northern Mexico, an "alliance" for gas distribution in the northern Mexico region of Baja California, a "realignment" of Tenneco assets purchased by El Paso and opportunities resulting in restructuring of the electric industry. Handwritten notes from that meeting are also cited.

The suit alleges that "the Phoenix meeting resulted in or was part of the formation and/or performance of an illegal agreement ... in which SoCal Gas, SDG&E and El Paso reciprocally agreed not to compete with one another, not to interfere with one another's economic interests, and to kill off competitive pipeline development projects that would threaten the dominance of the defendants in southern Nevada and southeastern California over the transportation, distribution and pricing of natural gas."

A central part of the conspiracy involved realignment of the assets of Tenneco, the suit says. Tenneco had been posing a threat to SoCal Gas' dominance in the region since the mid-1980s, with its Kern River pipeline project. However, El Paso acquired Tenneco in late 1996, and thereafter El Paso and the other defendants launched their conspiracy, the suit says.

"Tenneco's elimination of its Altamont expansion project to expand the Kern River pipeline (with low-cost gas from Canada and northern Montana), pursuant to El Paso's instructions, and its abandonment of its Baja California expansion project in exchange for El Paso's exclusive rights to the Samalayuca project was done pursuant to an unlawful agreement by El Paso, SoCal Gas and SDG&E to perpetuate the artificial geographic isolation of the gas markets at the border of Arizona and Southern California," the suit says.

The suit adds, "Preservation of the isolation of markets subject to prices determined at the Border Market preserved the market power of SoCal Gas and, later, El Paso, and perpetuated the exposure of Nevada Power to exploitation through the destruction of gas deliveries and artificial price increases."

The suit also alleges that as part of the Phoenix meeting, the defendants agreed not to interfere with each other's merger plans. At the time of the meeting, El Paso's acquisition of Tenneco was under discussion, and three weeks after the meeting the parent companies of SoCal Gas and SDG&E agreed to merge and form Sempra.

"Each knew the other could materially jeopardize the necessary regulatory approvals for their respective mergers," the suit says. "One of the purposes and motives of El Paso, SoCal Gas and SDG&E in making the unlawful agreements ... . was to secure each other's agreement not to oppose each other's merger deals and to cooperate in completing their respective acquisitions."

Regarding the alleged manipulation of natural gas prices indexes, the suit says El Paso Merchant Energy, Dynegy Marketing, Enron and possibly others "harmed plaintiffs and natural gas market competition by systematically misrepresenting the price and volume of their trades" to trade publications whose indexes are used in establishing prevailing industry prices. The suit said such misrepresentation started in 2000 and continued at least through the beginning of 2002, creating "the appearance of supply volatility and escalating prices."

The suit asserts claims for fraud, violation of Nevada's RICO Act and conspiracy to violate Nevada's RICO Act, compensatory damages, treble damages, punitive damages, legal fees, interest and other such relief deemed just and proper by the court. The suit seeks damages resulting from the alleged anti-competitive conduct in an amount of at least $150 million, plus treble damages of $450 million. Thus the suit seeks a minimum of $600 million in total damages.

About Sierra Pacific Resources

Headquartered in Nevada, Sierra Pacific Resources is a holding company whose principal subsidiaries are Nevada Power Company, the electric utility for most of southern Nevada, and Sierra Pacific Power Company, the electric utility for most of northern Nevada and the Lake Tahoe area of California. Sierra Pacific Power Company also distributes natural gas in the Reno-Sparks area of northern Nevada. Other subsidiaries include the Tuscarora Gas Pipeline Company, which owns 50 percent interest in an interstate natural gas transmission partnership and several unregulated energy services companies.

Sponsored by FLSmidth

Related Articles

Profiling Geothermal Energy in North America

North America holds diverse geologic conditions, economic and political contexts, and geothermal experiences.

Energy Reform Package to Increase Competition And Private Sector Opportunities in the Mexican Power Industry

In April, Mexican President Enrique Pena Nieto proposed a legislative reform package that was approved by the Mexican Congress, overhauling the nation's energy industries.

Follow Power Engineering on Twitter

Products Showcase

Dynamic Fluoride Ion cleaning DFIC of industrial natural gas turbines Hi-Tech Furnace Systems

Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning of IGT Parts

The Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning (DFIC) Process from Hi-Tech Furnace Systems is able to clean deep, narrow cracks of oxides by cycling between negative, atmospheric, and positive pressure.

Latest News

Shutterstock coal production trucks

Weekly Coal Production

The Weekly Coal Production shows how much coal is being produced across the U.S.

Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas Weekly Economic Indicators financial business

The Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas' Economic Indicators

The Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas offers a glimpse into how the markets are doing domestical...

Kvaerner awarded contract for gas-fired power plant in Delaware

Kvaerner North American Construction Inc. and its joint venture partner, Parsons Brinckerhoff...

Canadian Solar purchases two solar projects

Canadian Solar Inc. has acquired a majority interest in two utility-scale solar power project...

Operators Restart Unit 2 at PPL Susquehanna

Unit 2 at the PPL Susquehanna nuclear power plant near Berwick, Pa. resumed generating electr...

Settlement agreement limits cost recovery at Edwardsport

The Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission (IURC) on Dec. 27 modified and approved a settlemen...

Toshiba in talks to sell portion of Westinghouse nuclear unit

Toshiba Corp is in talks  to sell up to 16% of its stake in the Westinghouse Electric Co...

Utah nixes nuclear waste storage facility

Plans to park radioactive waste at a storage facility in Utah have been officially called off.

Archived Articles

2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013

Power Engineering Current Issue

03/01/2014
Volume 118, Issue 3
1403PE-cover

Buyers Guide Company Listings

Fluid Energy Controls Inc

Provides OEM custom bladder accumulators for lube oil systems (LOSA), surge suppressors, pulsation dampeners. Stainless steel, carbon steel. ASME, Canadian CRN, Brazilian NR-13, Chinese SELO/SQL, Malaysian DOSH, Australian AS1210.

DV INGENIERIA SRL

Manufactures Laseralignblue laser alignment instruments.

Graycor

Provides a wide variety of industrial and commercial contracting services, in addition to industrial maintenance services, throughout the US, Canada, Mexico and beyond.

Power Industry Wire News

UGE International Reports Third Quarter 2014 Financial Results

UGE International Reports Third Quarter 2014 Financial Results

Canadian Overseas Petroleum Limited Liberia Update

Canadian Overseas Petroleum Limited Liberia Update

American Leisure Holdings, Inc. Announces Letter of Intent to Acquire Wroblewski Oil and Gas Company

American Leisure Holdings, Inc. Announces Letter of Intent to Acquire Wroblewski Oil an...

Blue Earth Completes $10 Million Private Placement

Blue Earth Completes $10 Million Private Placement

Energy Services Company ENSERVCO to Present at LD Micro Conference

Energy Services Company ENSERVCO to Present at LD Micro Conference

Power Engineering

Article Archives for Power Engineering Magazine

Continuing Education

Professional Development Hours

To access a course listing associated to a specific topic listed below, click on the topic of choice from the list below.

Latest Energy Jobs

View more Job Listings >>


Power Engineering Newscasts

EPA chief: carbon caps will boost economy
Australia, Russia enter nuclear power agreement with Argentina
Largest battery energy storage in North America now operational
EPA chief: carbon caps will boost economy Largest battery energy storage in North America now operational Australia, Russia enter nuclear power agreement with Argentina Texas’ Panda Temple combined cycle plant up and running
Siemens agrees to acquire Dresser-Rand
Safety concrete poured at UAE nuclear reactor power project
Foster Wheeler to upgrade natural gas-fired power plant’s emission controls
GE, TransCanada partner on natural gas turbine design
Energy storage global market to grow to $15.6B by 2024; DOE awards $2M to support taller wind turbine towers; Hinkley Point C nuclear project have financial incentives approved; N.J. company building waste-to-energy project in Ireland