EPSA analysis: FERC's standard market design must allow for short-term price volatility

Washington, D.C., May 15, 2002 - Short-term price volatility is a natural characteristic of all well-functioning wholesale power markets and should be allowed to play its economic role in any standard market design (SMD) devised by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), according to principles and a supporting analysis released Tuesday by the Electric Power Supply Association (EPSA).

"While market mitigation is an important feature of FERC's SMD efforts, it is a poor substitute for the downward price pressure that's achievable through well-designed, well-functioning and truly competitive markets," said Julie Simon, EPSA's vice president of policy. "This is the essence and the guiding light of the principles we're filing today with the commission."

The accompanying research, performed independently by the Boston Pacific Co., covered public data from nine diverse electricity markets across the United States, and found that short-term price volatility was "pervasive" in all of them.

"Price volatility occurs in peak and off-peak periods, in all seasons, and in markets that have restructured for competition as well as in those that remain mostly regulated," according to the analysis. "In short, significant price volatility should be expected."

As part of its study, Boston Pacific also reviewed these markets from the perspective of a variety of hypothetical "price screens" and determined that such screens all have drawbacks.

"Because we fully accept the goal of retaining consumer confidence, we hoped for an approach that was less intrusive and arbitrary, and one that did not simply degenerate into another price cap," the study said. "Despite the significant research effort reported herein, we could not design such a price screen given the actual price history in the nine markets we analyzed."

Among other scenarios, the study conceded that the possibility of a SMD incorporating a $1,000/MWh bid cap could limit short-term volatility, but stipulated that this too could have adverse consequences.

"In the four Midwest markets that we researched, in which that cap does not already exist, the imposition of the demand-side proxy bid cap would lower price volatility and average market prices in these markets in almost all periods of time," the report said. "We must caution, however, that had the price spikes of 1998-1999 been quashed, the Midwest probably would not have seen the significant investment in new power plants that the region has enjoyed since that time."

According to the analysis, the answer to short-term volatility in wholesale spot markets is greater and more efficient access to multiple markets.

"Real-time markets are more volatile than day-ahead markets, and block forward markets are less volatile than day-ahead markets," according to the study. "Because of this, the commission already has a structural remedy available to address concerns with price volatility. That is, it can assure access to multiple markets.

"This, along with access to long-term contracts and risk-mitigation products, offers consumers and suppliers alike the opportunity to build a portfolio of purchases or sales to match their appetite for price volatility."

"We all agree that most consumers should be protected from the volatility of a real-time spot market," said Boston Pacific's Craig Roach, the author of the study. "One way to do that is to intervene in the real-time market and attempt to make it something it's not, a market without volatility. This has unintended consequences. The other is to enable consumers to stay out of the real-time spot market in the first place by assuring they have access to other markets and products. Based on our research, we support the latter."

For more information, visit www.epsa.org.


Sponsored by FLSmidth

Related Articles

Wisconsin Electric gets no bids to buy Presque Isle coal plant

Wisconsin Electric Power hasn't gotten any purchase bids at this point off a recent request for proposals (RFP) that it issued for the coal-fired Presque Isle power plant in Michigan's Upper Peninsula.

Gas, renewables account for new generation additions in February

Basin Electric Power Cooperative has commissioned its 45-MW Pioneer 2 peaking unit in North Dakota and it was the largest conventional peaking plant to come online during February as renewables accounted for the rest of the new generation.

Follow Power Engineering on Twitter

Latest News

[Image Gallery]

 Basin Electric wants to expand Williston-area power station

Basin Electric wants to expand Williston-area power station

Basin Electric Power Cooperative wants to expand the capacity of its 135-megawatt Pioneer Gen...
 Vermont House endorses renewable energy package

Vermont House endorses renewable energy package

The Vermont House has advanced a wide-ranging bill that pushes utilities beyond electricity t...
 W.Va. lawmakers clears bill touted by state's coal industry

W.Va. lawmakers clears bill touted by state's coal industry

West Virginia lawmakers have approved a proposal lauded by the struggling coal industry and c...
 Google invests $300Mn in SolarCity

Google invests $300Mn in SolarCity

Google Inc. is investing $300 million equity stake in a fund created by SolarCity Corp. to fi...
Solana

Power Engineering Photo of the Day

 France’s nuclear power plant shuts down due to pipe leak

France’s nuclear power plant shuts down due to pipe leak

Unit 1 at the Fessenheim nuclear power plant in France shut down Feb. 28 following the discov...
 Indian Point nuclear Unit 3 down for $50mn refueling outage

Indian Point nuclear Unit 3 down for $50mn refueling outage

Entergy (NYSE: ETR)’s Indian Point nuclear power plant Unit 3 in New York shut down for a pla...

Power Engineering Current Issue

03/01/2014
Volume 118, Issue 3
1403PE-cover

Products Showcase

Dynamic Fluoride Ion cleaning DFIC of industrial natural gas turbines Hi-Tech Furnace Systems

Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning of IGT Parts

The Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning (DFIC) Process from Hi-Tech Furnace Systems is able to clean deep, narrow cracks of oxides by cycling between negative, atmospheric, and positive pressure.

Archived Articles

2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013

Power Industry Wire News

SLI Global Solutions Joins the GLI Group of Companies

SLI Global Solutions Joins the GLI Group of Companies

FLIR Systems Announces Resignation of Chief Financial Officer and Promotion of Shane Harrison to Senior Vice President, Corporate Development and Strategy

FLIR Systems Announces Resignation of Chief Financial Officer and Promotion of Shane Ha...

American Eagle Energy Announces Operations and Reserves Update and Guidance

American Eagle Energy Announces Operations and Reserves Update and Guidance

Parsons Acquires T.J. Cross Engineers, Inc.

Parsons Acquires T.J. Cross Engineers, Inc.

Energy Experts Discuss 2015: Synergy Resources, Earthstone Energy, Fortis Energy Services, Samson Oil & Gas, Wunderlich Securities -- Exclusive Video Interviews With EnerCom's Oil & Gas 360(R)

Energy Experts Discuss 2015: Synergy Resources, Earthstone Energy, Fortis Energy Servic...

Power Engineering

Article Archives for Power Engineering Magazine

Continuing Education

Professional Development Hours

To access a course listing associated to a specific topic listed below, click on the topic of choice from the list below.

Latest Energy Jobs

View more Job Listings >>