Rules 'patchwork' impedes restructuring

DALLAS, Texas, Nov. 29, 2000--Deregulated natural gas and electricity markets also need liberalized business rules if competition is to flourish, several former U.S. government officials said Wednesday.

They spoke at the North American Summit on Harmonizing Business Practices, sponsored by the U.S. Energy Department and the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC).

The meeting's goal was to find ways to promote competition as natural gas and electricity markets are restructured.

Speakers said the differences among network companies�gas and electric distribution firms, pipelines, electric transmission companies, and independent system operators�have become barriers to the development of mature and competitive markets.

Robert Gee, former assistant U.S. Energy Secretary for fossil energy, said in the gas sector, restructuring has occurred primarily in the wholesale markets, because the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has oversight over all interstate gas pipelines.

Gee said although gas decontrol was complicated, it lacked the jurisdictional and other physical and engineering issues vexing the restructuring of the electricity sector. "Moreover, while natural gas retail regulatory reform has been slowly emerging, its adoption this far has occurred only on a limited geographic and state basis.

"By contrast, electric industry restructuring has been, and continues to be, more complex, owing to the long history of jurisdictional division of authority between state, federal, and local authorities."

He said there are myriad differences between the types of utilities (investor-owned, cooperatives, municipalities, and power authorities) and they often have unique physical and engineering configurations.

Gee said those complexities have been compounded by the state-by-state control of electricity. "What we have now, for better or worse, is an emerging patchwork of different blueprints for introducing retail competition.

"The necessary rules and procedures for electric retail competition are becoming embodied in state regulatory commission rules, individual retail access tariffs, and/or operating agreements and contracts. However, as states have begun introducing restructuring at the retail level, business rules have been varying significantly from state to state."

He argued that a lack of uniformity has the potential to be a significant impediment to the profitable market entry and operation of competitive energy service providers on a regional or national basis.

"The diversity in rules and procedures for providing essentially the same service in different areas may increase the costs to consumers and decrease the profits of some competitive providers.

"Absent harmonious rules an standards, truly competitive gas and electricity markets could be stunted. Uniform standards, on the other hand, hold the potential of lowering the cost for all market participants, lowering barriers to market entry, and easing the movement of capital, goods, and services. Buyers and sellers wold then have more choices and better opportunities to recognize the value of a competitive market," Gee said.

He also said any potential standards also should be drafted to include transboundary transactions, in recognition of the growing North American energy market.

Energy policy
Branko Terzic, director of public utility services for the Deloitte & Touche consulting firm, said state-by-state regulations have resulted in a diversity of business rules.

Terzic, a former U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission member, said: "We have a patchwork of government rules, and it doesn't have a national vision."

In contrast, he said the European Commission�representing a variety of nations�has established electricity and natural gas directives with goals and deadlines. The overall objective in Europe is economic efficiency of energy markets.

Terzic noted that in the U.S., there is not even a national policy that declares the production of electricity should be cost-competitive. "We can talk about the needs for voluntary business practices, but we need to agree on national energy goals first."

He said the old Federal Power Act has a neglected provision that would allow FERC to convene a board to harmonize U.S. electricity practices, and the commission should consider activating it.

Tom Casden, chairman and CEO of Americas Power Partners, said the most efficient segment of the electricity generating market is distributed generation. But he said most state regulatory commissions were established to regulate large central generating plants, and their rules act as a barrier to the more efficient smaller plants. "Talk about a crazy quilt. There is no logic to it."

Casden said the only goal of government energy policy should be to drive the costs of generating power and the resulting pollution as close to zero as possible.

Gary Nakarado, of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, discussed a recent study by the lab.

It found that the electricity industry needed uniform technical standards for interconnection to the grid. After the technical issues are resolved, he said governments should review their rules to ensure they are fair to potential market entrants.

Sponsored by FLSmidth

Related Articles

Regulators OK steep National Grid rate increase

Utility regulators have approved a steep increase in electricity rates but will spread the costs out over all of next year to ease the impact on consumers.

Mergers, EPA carbon plan generated much attention during 2014

Mergers, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Clean Power Plan, cheap natural gas and the polar vortex were among the most noteworthy generation stories of 2014.

Follow Power Engineering on Twitter
Latest News
Plant Vogtle construction costs down in first half 2015

Plant Vogtle nuclear expansion spending down in first half of 2015

Georgia Power said in a report that the utility estimates it will spend less on construction ...
Renewable energy developer Cypress Creek Renewables building 2 utility-scale solar farms in South Carolina

Renewable energy developer Cypress Creek Renewables building 2 utility-scale solar farms in South Carolina

Cypress Creek Renewables is investing more than $20 million in new projects in South Carolina.
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission on Thursday cited a

US regulators, Millstone nuke plant settle dispute

The parent company of Connecticut's nuclear plant and federal regulators have reached a settl...
Duke Energy is looking to bring 53 MW of utility-scale solar capacity to the company’s South Carolina service areas by the end of 2016.

Duke Energy launching solar-generating program for South Carolina customers

Duke Energy is looking to bring 53 MW of utility-scale solar capacity to the company’s South ...
The state Department of Natural Resources says historic amounts of oil and natural gas are being produced by Ohio shale wells.

State says Ohio oil, natural gas production at historic high

The state Department of Natural Resources says historic amounts of oil and natural gas are be...
MidAmerican Energy says it will build its next two wind farms in northwest Iowa.

MidAmerican Energy building Iowa wind farms for $900 million

MidAmerican Energy says it will build its next two wind farms in northwest Iowa.

Semprius, Inc. awarded $2.9 million to develop low-cost, solar-generated electricity

Semprius awarded $2.9 million from ARPA-E to develop hybrid solar technology

Semprius, Inc., an innovator in high concentration photovoltaic (HCPV) solar modules, has bee...
08/26 Henry Hub Average Natural Gas Spot Prices

08/26 Henry Hub Average Natural Gas Spot Prices

The Henry Hub is the pricing point for natural gas futures contracts traded on the New York M...

Power Engineering Current Issue

12/01/2014
Volume 118, Issue 12
1412pe-cover
Products Showcase
Dynamic Fluoride Ion cleaning DFIC of industrial natural gas turbines Hi-Tech Furnace Systems

Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning of IGT Parts

The Dynamic Fluoride Ion Cleaning (DFIC) Process from Hi-Tech Furnace Systems is able to clean deep, narrow cracks of oxides by cycling between negative, atmospheric, and positive pressure.

Archived Articles

2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013

Power Industry Wire News

Mid-Atlantic Aviation Partnership to Explore Tethered Drone Commercialization With Drone Aviation Holding Corp.

Mid-Atlantic Aviation Partnership to Explore Tethered Drone Commercialization With Dron...

Perma-Fix Medical S.A. Announces Successful Completion of 6 Curie Tests With Scale-Up of Its Non-Uranium Process to Procure Technetium-99m

Perma-Fix Medical S.A. Announces Successful Completion of 6 Curie Tests With Scale-Up o...

Power, Rail, Pharma Lead Northeast in $100 Billion of Planned Projects, an Industrial Info News Alert

Power, Rail, Pharma Lead Northeast in $100 Billion of Planned Projects, an Industrial I...

LNG, Chemicals Drive Top 10 Capital-Spending Projects in U.S. Mid-Atlantic, Although Power Projects Face Delays, an Industrial Info News Alert

LNG, Chemicals Drive Top 10 Capital-Spending Projects in U.S. Mid-Atlantic, Although Po...

PyroGenesis Canada Inc. to Present at the 4th Annual Liolios Gateway Conference on September 10, 2015

PyroGenesis Canada Inc. to Present at the 4th Annual Liolios Gateway Conference on Sept...

Power Engineering

Article Archives for Power Engineering Magazine

Continuing Education

Professional Development Hours

To access a course listing associated to a specific topic listed below, click on the topic of choice from the list below.

Latest Energy Jobs

View more Job Listings >>